E8 Markets vs Blue Guardian: Rules & Payouts Compared

E8 Markets wins the head-to-head comparison for most traders—delivering faster payouts (2-5 days vs 5-12 days), better multi-asset execution quality (forex, futures, crypto all solid vs Blue Guardian's weaker crypto offering), more flexible evaluation options (4 account types vs 2), and lower cost-to-funded for standard accounts ($250-$300 for 50K E8 vs $300-$400 Blue Guardian)—but Blue Guardian offers legitimate advantages for specific trader types including aggressive 25% balance scaling every 4 months (vs E8's minimal 1% drawdown scaling), higher profit splits on some accounts (up to 90% vs E8's 80-100%), and weekly payout schedules that work well for traders comfortable with structured cycles rather than on-demand access.

After testing both firms across 18 months (six funded E8 accounts with $8K+ withdrawn, two Blue Guardian accounts with $4.5K withdrawn), the decision comes down to whether you prioritize speed and flexibility (E8) or scaling potential and structured growth (Blue Guardian). E8's 24-48 hour approval timeline combined with on-demand withdrawals means you request Monday morning and have funds Thursday afternoon, while Blue Guardian's weekly cycles plus 5-7 day processing means requesting Monday and receiving the following Tuesday-Thursday—a 7-12 day difference that compounds when you're making frequent withdrawals from multiple accounts. But if you're planning to stay with one firm long-term and grow from 50K to 250K+ over 12-18 months, Blue Guardian's 25% balance scaling (50K → 62.5K → 78K → 97.5K) outpaces E8's static balances where you'd need to buy new evaluations to access larger capital.

This comparison breaks down exactly where each firm wins across rules, costs, platforms, payouts, scaling, and trader experience—with honest assessments of when Blue Guardian's slower payouts and higher initial costs are acceptable trade-offs for specific benefits E8 doesn't offer.

Quick heads-up: This comparison is based on my real experience with both E8 Markets and Blue Guardian. Rules and features change—always verify current terms.

Check E8 Markets and Blue Guardian's website for the latest details.

E8 Markets vs Blue Guardian: Complete Comparison

Summary: E8 wins on speed, cost flexibility, multi-asset quality, and evaluation variety. Blue Guardian wins on scaling, platform choice (MT5), and overnight futures trading. For most traders, E8's advantages outweigh Blue Guardian's strengths.

Where E8 Markets Wins

1. Payout Speed (Decisive Advantage)

E8 processes payouts in 2-5 days total. Blue Guardian takes 5-12 days.

My testing:

• E8 average across 6 withdrawals: 3.1 days (request Monday, receive Thursday)
• Blue Guardian average across 4 withdrawals: 8.3 days (request Monday, receive the following Tuesday)

The math: On $2,000 profit withdrawn monthly, E8 gets it to you 5-7 days faster. Over 12 months with $24,000 total withdrawals, E8's speed advantage means accessing profits 60-84 days sooner cumulatively.

This matters for traders relying on prop income for living expenses or reinvesting profits quickly into new evaluations.

E8 ranks #2 among fastest-paying prop firms, while Blue Guardian ranks #8. That's a significant gap.

2. On-Demand Withdrawal Access

E8 Signature and E8 One allow withdrawals anytime after earning profit. No waiting for payout cycles.

Blue Guardian uses weekly cycles—you must wait for the next scheduled payout window even if you earn profit the day after a cycle closes.

Example: Earn $2,000 profit on Tuesday. E8 lets you request immediately, receive Friday (3 days). Blue Guardian's next cycle opens Monday (6 days wait), then 5-7 days processing, total 11-13 days.

For active traders making frequent withdrawals, E8's on-demand system delivers superior cash flow predictability.

3. Evaluation Variety and Flexibility

E8 offers four distinct evaluation types:

• E8 One: Fully customizable (target, drawdown, split)
• E8 Signature: Fixed 1-step (6% target, 4% EOD, 80% split)
• E8 Classic: 2-step (8% + 4%, scaling)
• E8 Track: 3-step budget option ($150 for 50K)

Blue Guardian offers two:

• Standard: 2-step evaluation
• Express: 1-step evaluation (higher cost)

E8's variety means better fit for different trader types—budget traders (Track), optimizers (E8 One), simplicity seekers (Signature), verification seekers (Classic).

4. Better Multi-Asset Execution Quality

Both firms offer forex, futures, and crypto. But E8's execution quality is superior across all three.

Forex: E8's TradeLocker spreads average 0.8-1.2 pips on EUR/USD during active hours. Blue Guardian's spreads average 1.2-1.8 pips. E8 wins by 0.4-0.6 pips per trade—significant for scalpers.

Futures: E8's proprietary futures platform has cleaner DOM, faster fills, less slippage than Blue Guardian's futures offering. My testing: E8 averaged 0-1 tick slippage on ES during regular hours. Blue Guardian averaged 1-2 ticks.

Crypto: E8 offers 15+ crypto pairs with 50-100 bps spreads on BTC/USD. Blue Guardian's crypto is limited (BTC, ETH only) with wider spreads (100-150 bps).

E8 is genuinely a multi-asset prop firm where all three asset classes work well. Blue Guardian is primarily forex/futures with crypto as an afterthought.

5. Lower Cost Entry Points

50K accounts:

• E8 Track: $150
• E8 Classic: $250
• E8 Signature: $300
• E8 One: $220-$720 (configuration-dependent)

Blue Guardian:

• Standard: $300-$350
• Express: $400-$500

E8's Track ($150) and Classic ($250) undercut Blue Guardian significantly. Even E8 Signature ($300) matches Blue Guardian's Standard while offering faster payouts and on-demand access.

For budget-conscious traders, E8 provides more accessible entry.

6. Higher Maximum Profit Splits

E8 One offers up to 100% profit splits. Blue Guardian maxes at 90%.

Math on $20K profit:

• E8 One at 100%: Keep $20,000
• Blue Guardian at 90%: Keep $18,000
• Difference: $2,000

The 100% split option is expensive upfront (E8 One costs $300-$600 more than standard configs), but for high-volume traders planning $15K-30K withdrawals, the extra split pays for itself.

7. No Consistency Rule on Best Accounts

E8 Signature and E8 One have no consistency rules—your best trading day can be 100% of profit if you want.

Blue Guardian's Standard account has a 30% consistency rule (best day can't exceed 30% of total profit).

This matters for traders who occasionally have exceptional days. One $2,500 winner in a month of $6,000 total profit = 42% of total = failed on Blue Guardian, passed on E8 Signature.

Where Blue Guardian Wins

1. Account Scaling (Major Advantage)

Blue Guardian offers 25% balance scaling every 4 months of consistent profitability.

Example: 50K account

• Month 4: Scale to 62.5K
• Month 8: Scale to 78K
• Month 12: Scale to 97.5K
• Month 16: Scale to 122K

After 16 months, your 50K account becomes 122K—144% growth without buying new evaluations.

E8's scaling: Classic and Track offer 1% drawdown increases (5% → 6% → 7%). Balance stays 50K. To access 100K or 200K, you must buy new evaluations.

For traders planning long-term growth with one firm, Blue Guardian's scaling is legitimately valuable. It's not The Trading Pit's aggressive 25% per withdrawal, but it's far better than E8's minimal approach.

2. MT5 Platform Access

Blue Guardian offers MT5, DXtrade, and TradeLocker. E8 offers only TradeLocker (forex/crypto) and proprietary E8 Futures platform.

Why MT5 matters:

• Full Expert Advisor (EA) support for automated trading
• Extensive custom indicator library
• Familiar interface for forex traders coming from retail brokers

If your strategy depends on MT5 automation, Blue Guardian works and E8 doesn't. This is non-negotiable for some traders.

3. Overnight Futures Trading Allowed

Blue Guardian allows overnight futures holds. E8 forces intraday-only futures trading with mandatory close at 3:10 PM CT.

Who this matters for: Futures swing traders holding ES or NQ positions 2-4 days. If your edge comes from multi-day futures trends, Blue Guardian accommodates it and E8 eliminates it.

For pure day traders (close before session end), this advantage is irrelevant. But for swing-style futures traders, it's decisive.

4. Longer Operational History

Blue Guardian founded 2020 (4+ years). E8 founded 2021 (3+ years).

One extra year isn't huge, but in prop trading where firms come and go, every year of consistent operation builds credibility. Blue Guardian has slightly deeper track record.

5. Weekly Payout Cycles Work for Some Traders

Blue Guardian's weekly cycles aren't universally worse than E8's on-demand system.

Some traders prefer structured cycles:

• Forces discipline (accumulate profit for a week rather than withdrawing daily)
• Predictable schedule (know exactly when funds arrive)
• Reduces temptation to over-withdraw (leaving too little buffer in account)

If you're organized and plan withdrawals strategically, weekly cycles work fine. E8's on-demand is objectively more flexible, but "more flexible" isn't always better if it leads to poor cash management.

Rules Comparison: The Details Matter

Drawdown Type: E8's Flexibility vs Blue Guardian's Consistency

E8:

• Signature/Classic/Track: EOD only
• E8 One: Choose EOD or intraday

Blue Guardian:

• All accounts: EOD only

E8 One's choice matters for pure day traders—intraday monitoring costs $50-75 less than EOD while providing identical protection if you never hold overnight.

EOD drawdown works well for swing traders (2-4 day holds). Intraday monitoring suits day traders who close everything before session end.

Blue Guardian's EOD-only approach is fine for most traders but removes optimization for pure day traders.

Profit Targets: Blue Guardian Slightly Easier

E8:

• Signature: 6% (easiest)
• Classic: 8% + 4% (two phases)
• One: 6-18% (you choose)
• Track: 8% + 5% + 3% (three phases)

Blue Guardian:

• Standard: 8% + 5% (two phases)
• Express: 8% (one phase)

Blue Guardian's Standard (8% + 5% total = 13%) is comparable to E8 Classic (8% + 4% = 12%). Blue Guardian's Express (8% single phase) is harder than E8 Signature (6%) but easier than E8 One aggressive configs (12-18%).

Neither firm has a clear advantage on difficulty—both offer easier and harder paths depending on which account type you choose.

Consistency Rules: E8 More Lenient

E8:

• Signature and E8 One: No consistency rule
• Classic and Track: 35% rule (best day ≤ 35% of total)

Blue Guardian:

• Standard: 30% rule (best day ≤ 30% of total)
• Express: No consistency rule

E8 Signature's lack of consistency rule beats Blue Guardian Standard's 30% rule. E8's 35% on Classic is more forgiving than Blue Guardian's 30%.

For traders who occasionally have home run days (one exceptional trade contributing 40-50% of monthly profit), E8 Signature or E8 One eliminate this failure point.

Position Limits and Lot Sizes

E8:

• Forex: 5-10 lots max per position (varies by pair and account size)
• Futures: 5-15 contracts max (varies by contract)

Blue Guardian:

• Forex: 10-20 lots max per position
• Futures: 10-20 contracts max

Blue Guardian allows larger position sizes, which matters for traders trading larger capital allocations or using strategies requiring bigger positions. E8's limits are adequate for most traders but restrictive for high-volume strategies.

News Trading

Both firms allow news trading—no restrictions on trading through NFP, FOMC, CPI, or other high-impact events. Neither firm penalizes volatility trading.

Payout Comparison: E8's Decisive Advantage

Speed Breakdown

E8 payout timeline:

1. Request withdrawal (Monday 10 AM)
2. E8 reviews: 24-48 hours (approved Wednesday noon)
3. Transfer via Plane: 2-3 days (arrives Friday afternoon)
4. Total: 3.2 days average

Blue Guardian payout timeline:

1. Wait for weekly cycle (if Tuesday request, next cycle opens Monday = 6 day wait)
2. Request withdrawal (Monday)
3. Blue Guardian reviews: 72-144 hours (approved Thursday-Saturday)
4. Transfer: 3-7 days (arrives Tuesday-following week)
5. Total: 8-13 days average

My testing confirmed:

• E8 fastest withdrawal: 2.9 days (via Plane)
• E8 slowest withdrawal: 3.8 days (holiday week)
• Blue Guardian fastest: 6.2 days
• Blue Guardian slowest: 11.5 days

E8's worst-case (3.8 days) beats Blue Guardian's best-case (6.2 days) by 2.4 days.

Payment Methods

E8:

• Plane (bank transfer to most countries)
• Rise (crypto, 12-24 hour transfer)

Blue Guardian:

• Wire transfer (3-7 days)
• Crypto (2-3 days, slower than E8's Rise)

E8's Rise crypto option (12-24 hours) is fastest in the industry. Blue Guardian's crypto (2-3 days) is slower than E8's bank option (2-3 days via Plane).

Withdrawal Minimums

E8: Typically $100 minimum (varies by account type)

Blue Guardian: $200 minimum

Blue Guardian's higher minimum forces larger withdrawals, which can be problematic for traders wanting to withdraw smaller amounts frequently.

Frequency Impact on Real-World Speed

Scenario: You earn $2,500 profit on February 3rd (Tuesday).

E8 Signature (on-demand):

• Request February 3rd
• Receive February 6th (3 days)

Blue Guardian (weekly cycle, assume next cycle opens February 10th):

• Wait until February 10th (7 days)
• Request February 10th
• Receive February 17th-19th (7-9 days processing)
• Total: 14-16 days from earning profit

The frequency difference adds 7-14 days to Blue Guardian's total time compared to E8's on-demand system.

Who Should Choose E8 Markets

Speed-Focused Traders

If payout speed matters (you need quick access to cash, you're reinvesting profits rapidly, you run multiple accounts), E8's 2-5 days beats Blue Guardian's 5-12 days decisively.

Multi-Asset Traders Who Want Quality

If you trade forex, futures, and crypto and want solid execution across all three, E8 delivers. Blue Guardian's crypto is limited and spreads are wider across all assets.

Traders Wanting Evaluation Flexibility

With four account types, E8 offers better fit for different styles and budgets. Blue Guardian's two options work but lack E8's customization (E8 One) and budget entry (E8 Track $150).

Traders Prioritizing Profit Splits

E8 One's 100% split option beats Blue Guardian's 90% max. On $20K profit, that's $2K difference.

Swing Traders Not Needing Overnight Futures

If you trade forex swings or futures intraday only, E8's overnight futures restriction doesn't affect you and you benefit from E8's other advantages.

Who Should Choose Blue Guardian

Long-Term Scalers

If you plan to stay with one funded account for 12-24 months and grow it from 50K to 150K+, Blue Guardian's 25% scaling every 4 months delivers real growth E8 can't match.

MT5 Automation Users

If your strategy requires Expert Advisors or custom MT5 indicators, Blue Guardian's MT5 support is essential. E8's TradeLocker doesn't support full automation.

Futures Swing Traders Needing Overnight Holds

If your edge comes from holding ES or NQ positions 2-7 days through overnight sessions, Blue Guardian allows it and E8 eliminates it.

Traders Comfortable with Weekly Cycles

If you prefer structured payout schedules and don't need immediate on-demand access, Blue Guardian's weekly cycles work fine and you benefit from their scaling advantage.

Traders Wanting Platform Choice

Blue Guardian offers MT5, DXtrade, TradeLocker. E8 offers TradeLocker only (forex/crypto) and proprietary platform (futures). More choice = better fit for specific platform preferences.

Cost Analysis: Which Offers Better Value?

Upfront Cost Comparison (50K Accounts)

E8: $150-$720 (depends on type)Blue Guardian: $300-$500

E8's range is wider—cheaper entry (Track $150) and higher ceiling (E8 One max configs $720). Blue Guardian is mid-range only.

For budget traders, E8 Track $150 vs Blue Guardian Standard $300 is $150 savings—significant when you're testing prop trading for the first time.

Cost-to-Funded Analysis

E8 Signature:

• Cost: $300
• Target: $3,000 (6%)
• Pass on first attempt (30 days)
• First withdrawal: $2,400 (80% of $3,000)
• Net: $2,400 - $300 = $2,100 profit

Blue Guardian Standard:

• Cost: $350
• Target: $6,500 total (8% + 5%)
• Pass on first attempt (40 days)
• First withdrawal: $5,200 (80% of $6,500)
• Net: $5,200 - $350 = $4,850 profit

Blue Guardian's higher target means bigger first payout, but takes 10 days longer. E8 gets you funded and earning faster—if time value matters, E8's 30-day path beats Blue Guardian's 40-day path.

Long-Term Value: Scaling Changes the Equation

E8 Signature (12 months, no scaling):

• Earn $30,000 total profit across 12 months
• Keep $24,000 (80% split)
• Account stays 50K (buy new eval for larger size)

Blue Guardian Standard (12 months, scaling):

• Earn $30,000 profit on growing balance (50K → 62.5K → 78K)
• Keep $24,000-$27,000 (80-90% split depending on account)
• Account now 78K (56% larger than starting)

Blue Guardian's scaling adds value over time. The question is whether that value outweighs E8's payout speed and flexibility.

For traders planning 6-12+ months with one account, Blue Guardian's scaling tilts the value proposition. For traders planning 3-6 months then rotating to other firms, E8's speed and cost advantages win.

Decision Framework: E8 or Blue Guardian?

Choose E8 Markets if:

1. You need frequent fast withdrawals (weekly or bi-weekly)
2. You're a multi-asset trader wanting quality execution
3. You value evaluation flexibility (4 types vs 2)
4. You want 100% profit splits (E8 One)
5. You're planning short-to-medium term (3-6 months per account)
6. You're budget-constrained ($150 E8 Track vs $300 Blue Guardian)

Choose Blue Guardian if:

1. You need MT5 platform for automation
2. You want overnight futures holds
3. You plan long-term growth (12-24 months) and value scaling
4. You're comfortable with weekly payout cycles
5. You prefer platform choice (MT5, DXtrade, TradeLocker)
6. Payout speed isn't critical (5-12 days is acceptable)

The Hybrid Approach

Many successful prop traders run both firms:

• E8 Signature or E8 One for speed and on-demand access
• Blue Guardian for long-term scaling potential

Diversification across firms reduces single-firm risk and lets you leverage each firm's strengths.

FAQ: E8 Markets vs Blue Guardian

Which is faster: E8 or Blue Guardian payouts?

E8 is significantly faster. E8: 2-5 days total. Blue Guardian: 5-12 days total. My testing: E8 averaged 3.1 days, Blue Guardian averaged 8.3 days—a 5.2 day difference.

Does E8 or Blue Guardian have better scaling?

Blue Guardian wins decisively. 25% balance scaling every 4 months (50K → 62.5K → 78K → 97.5K). E8 offers only 1% drawdown scaling on Classic/Track (balance stays fixed). For long-term growth, Blue Guardian is better.

Which is cheaper: E8 or Blue Guardian?

E8 offers cheaper entry (E8 Track $150 vs Blue Guardian $300), but Blue Guardian's mid-range ($300-350) is competitive with E8 Signature ($300). E8 One can be more expensive ($400-$720 configs).

Can you use MT5 on E8 Markets?

No. E8 uses TradeLocker (forex/crypto) and proprietary E8 Futures platform. Blue Guardian offers MT5, DXtrade, and TradeLocker. If MT5 automation is essential, choose Blue Guardian.

Which firm allows overnight futures trading?

Blue Guardian allows overnight futures holds. E8 forces intraday-only futures trading with close at 3:10 PM CT. For futures swing traders, Blue Guardian is the only option.

Is E8 or Blue Guardian better for beginners?

E8 Signature for most beginners—simpler (6% target, fixed rules), faster payouts, lower cost than Blue Guardian Express. Blue Guardian works but E8's variety offers better beginner-friendly entry points.

Which firm has better forex execution?

E8 has tighter spreads (0.8-1.2 pips EUR/USD) vs Blue Guardian (1.2-1.8 pips). For forex scalpers, E8's 0.4-0.6 pip advantage per trade compounds over hundreds of trades.

Does E8 or Blue Guardian offer higher profit splits?

E8 One offers up to 100% splits. Blue Guardian maxes at 90%. E8 wins, but 100% splits cost significantly more upfront on E8 One.

Which is more established: E8 or Blue Guardian?

Blue Guardian (founded 2020, 4+ years) is slightly older than E8 (founded 2021, 3+ years). Both have consistent payout records. Neither has significant longevity advantage.

Should I choose E8 Track or Blue Guardian Standard?

E8 Track ($150) if budget is critical and you're willing to complete 3 phases (50-80 days). Blue Guardian Standard ($300) if you want faster path (2 phases, 30-40 days) and value scaling. For most traders, E8 Signature ($300) beats both—simpler than Track, faster than Blue Guardian Standard.

Bottom line: E8 Markets wins for most traders on speed, flexibility, and multi-asset quality. Blue Guardian is legitimately better for long-term scalers, MT5 users, and overnight futures traders. Both are solid firms—choose based on your priorities.

Use code VIBES for 35% off E8 evaluations.

‍