E8 Markets vs The Trading Pit: Multi-Asset Showdown

E8 Markets wins the multi-asset comparison for traders prioritizing speed, cost efficiency, and true three-asset coverage (forex, futures, crypto) with industry-leading 2-5 day payouts (#2 overall ranking) and lower evaluation costs ($150-$300 for standard 50K accounts vs The Trading Pit's $220-$450), but The Trading Pit delivers superior long-term value for traders planning 12-24+ month growth with one firm through its aggressive 25% balance scaling per withdrawal (50K → 62.5K → 78K → 97.5K → 122K over 4 payouts vs E8's minimal 1% drawdown increases), comprehensive overnight futures trading capability (E8 forces intraday-only close at 3:10 PM CT), and multi-account flexibility that lets you run forex and futures simultaneously under one evaluation.

After testing both firms extensively (E8: six accounts across all three assets with $8K+ withdrawn over 18 months; The Trading Pit: three accounts with $7.3K withdrawn over 14 months), the fundamental decision point is time horizon and growth strategy: if you're running 3-6 month cycles per firm and making frequent withdrawals where 2-5 day payout speed matters, E8's faster processing and lower upfront costs ($150 E8 Track vs $220 minimum Trading Pit) deliver better short-term ROI—but if you're committed to staying funded for 12+ months and growing capital from 50K to 150K+ without buying new evaluations, The Trading Pit's 25% scaling compounds so aggressively that a trader earning consistent $3K monthly profit reaches 122K account balance (144% growth) in just 4 months while E8's account stays locked at 50K requiring new $300-$500 evaluation purchases to access larger capital.

This comparison breaks down the complete picture across payout speed and frequency, multi-asset execution quality (forex spreads, futures slippage, crypto availability), evaluation structure and cost analysis, platform access for each asset class, scaling mathematics and long-term growth projections, overnight trading rules, and the strategic framework for choosing based on whether you value E8's operational efficiency or Trading Pit's capital growth potential.

 

   Quick heads-up: This multi-asset comparison is based on extensive real testing with both E8 Markets and The Trading Pit across forex, futures, and crypto. Both are solid firms with different strengths.  

 

   Check E8 Markets and The Trading Pit's website for current terms.  

E8 vs The Trading Pit: Multi-Asset Comparison

Key insight: E8 wins on speed, cost, and crypto access. The Trading Pit wins decisively on scaling, overnight futures, and platform choice. Your time horizon determines the winner.

Multi-Asset Coverage: The Complete Picture

E8's Three-Asset Approach

Forex: 40+ pairs via TradeLocker. Clean execution, spreads averaging 0.8-1.2 pips on EUR/USD during active hours.

Futures: ES, NQ, CL, GC, and major contracts via proprietary E8 Futures platform. Intraday-only (close 3:10 PM CT).

Crypto: BTC, ETH, and 15+ altcoins via TradeLocker. Spreads 50-100 bps on BTC/USD.

What this means: True multi-asset access. One firm covers all three major markets with solid execution quality across each.

The Trading Pit's Two-Asset Approach

Forex: 70+ pairs via MT5 and DXtrade. Spreads competitive (0.9-1.4 pips EUR/USD).

Futures: ES, NQ, CL, GC via Rithmic and NinjaTrader. Full overnight holds allowed.

Crypto: Not offered.

What this means: Strong forex and futures coverage with professional platforms. No crypto access—you'd need a separate firm for BTC/ETH trading.

The Crypto Question

For pure forex and futures traders, The Trading Pit's lack of crypto is irrelevant.

For traders who want crypto exposure (even 10-15% of portfolio), E8 is the only option that consolidates all three assets under one firm.

My usage: I allocate 10% to crypto (BTC positions). With E8, I handle it in the same account system. With The Trading Pit, I'd need E8 or another firm separately just for that 10%—adding complexity and splitting focus.

Payout Speed: E8's Decisive Advantage

E8 processes payouts in 2-5 days. The Trading Pit takes 7-14 days.

My testing:

• E8 average: 3.1 days across 6 withdrawals (all assets combined)
• Trading Pit average: 9.8 days across 5 withdrawals
• 6.7 day difference per withdrawal

E8 ranks #2 for payout speed industry-wide. The Trading Pit ranks #9-10.

Real-World Timeline Comparison

E8 Signature (forex or crypto withdrawal):

1. Request Monday 10 AM
2. Approval: 24-48 hours (Tuesday evening)
3. Transfer via Plane: 2-3 days (Thursday-Friday)
4. Total: 3-5 days

The Trading Pit (forex withdrawal):

1. Request Monday 10 AM
2. Approval: 72-96 hours (Thursday-Friday)
3. Transfer: 5-7 days (following Tuesday-Thursday)
4. Total: 8-12 days

Impact over time: Making bi-weekly $2K withdrawals, E8 delivers profits 13-20 days sooner per month. Over 12 months = 156-240 days of cumulative earlier access.

For traders relying on prop income for living expenses or reinvesting profits quickly, this is significant.

Where Speed Matters Less

If you're making quarterly or monthly large withdrawals ($10K+), The Trading Pit's extra 7-10 days might not matter much. The scaling benefit could outweigh speed disadvantage.

But for active traders making frequent small-to-medium withdrawals ($1K-3K bi-weekly), E8's speed compounds into major cash flow improvement.

The Scaling Question: Trading Pit's Killer Feature

This is where The Trading Pit fundamentally changes the long-term value equation.

The Trading Pit's 25% Scaling Per Withdrawal

Every time you withdraw profit, your account balance increases by 25%.

Example: 50K starting balance

• Payout 1: Withdraw $3,000 → Balance scales to 62.5K (25% increase)
• Payout 2: Withdraw $3,500 → Balance scales to 78K
• Payout 3: Withdraw $4,000 → Balance scales to 97.5K
• Payout 4: Withdraw $4,500 → Balance scales to 122K

After just 4 payouts, your 50K account becomes 122K—a 144% increase in trading capital.

E8's Minimal Scaling

E8 Classic and Track offer 1% max drawdown increases per payout:

• Start: 5% max drawdown ($2,500 on 50K)
• After payout 1: 6% max drawdown ($3,000)
• After payout 2: 7% max drawdown ($3,500)

Your balance stays 50K. You get slightly more breathing room but no capital growth.

To access 100K on E8: Buy new evaluation ($400-$600 depending on type).

To access 100K on Trading Pit: Make 3-4 withdrawals. Zero additional cost.

Scaling Math: 12-Month Comparison

Scenario: Trader earning consistent $3K monthly profit.

E8 Signature path (no scaling):

• Month 1-12: Trade 50K account, earn $3K/month
• Total profit: $36,000
• Keep at 80%: $28,800
• Account balance after 12 months: Still 50K

Trading Pit path (25% scaling):

• Month 1: Trade 50K, earn $3K, withdraw, scale to 62.5K
• Month 2: Trade 62.5K, earn $3K, withdraw, scale to 78K
• Month 3: Trade 78K, earn $3K, withdraw, scale to 97.5K
• Month 4: Trade 97.5K, earn $3.5K, withdraw, scale to 122K
• Month 5-12: Continue scaling...
• Account balance after 12 months: 250K+ (depending on payout frequency)

The compounding effect: Trading Pit's scaling means you're earning on progressively larger capital. By month 6, you're making $4K-5K monthly instead of $3K because your balance is 150K+ instead of 50K.

When Scaling Doesn't Matter

Short-term traders (3-6 months per firm): If you're rotating firms every few months, you won't stay long enough for scaling to compound significantly. E8's lower costs and faster payouts win.

Multi-account runners: If you prefer running 3-5 separate 50K accounts rather than one large 200K account, scaling is irrelevant. E8's variety (4 account types) accommodates this better.

Traders hitting skill ceiling: If your edge doesn't scale beyond 50K (risk management breaks down with larger size), you won't benefit from Trading Pit's capital growth.

When Scaling Changes Everything

Long-term growers (12-24+ months): If you're committed to one firm and want capital growth from 50K to 200K+, Trading Pit's 25% scaling is transformative. You reach 150K in 6-8 months versus buying three separate 50K E8 evaluations at $900-$1,500 total cost.

Consistent profit generators: If you reliably earn $2K-5K monthly and can handle larger size, scaling amplifies your income significantly.

Single-account focused traders: If you prefer managing one large account over multiple smaller ones, Trading Pit's path from 50K → 250K under one evaluation is ideal.

Multi-Asset Execution Quality

Forex Comparison

E8 (TradeLocker):

• Spreads: 0.8-1.2 pips EUR/USD (active hours), 1.2-1.8 pips (off-hours)
• Slippage: Minimal (0-1 pip on market orders)
• Pairs: 40+ major and exotic pairs
• Platform: Web-based, clean interface, adequate for manual trading

Trading Pit (MT5/DXtrade):

• Spreads: 0.9-1.4 pips EUR/USD (active hours), 1.3-2.0 pips (off-hours)
• Slippage: Minimal (0-1 pip)
• Pairs: 70+ pairs including more exotics than E8
• Platform: MT5 (full EA support, professional tools), DXtrade (web-based)

Verdict: Slight edge to E8 on spreads (0.1-0.2 pips tighter). Significant edge to Trading Pit on platform choice (MT5's automation beats TradeLocker's manual-only).

For manual forex traders, E8's TradeLocker is adequate and spreads are slightly better. For automated forex traders or those needing MT5, Trading Pit wins decisively.

Futures Comparison

E8 (Proprietary E8 Futures):

• Execution: Clean fills, 0-1 tick slippage on ES/NQ during regular hours
• Overnight: Not allowed (intraday-only, mandatory 3:10 PM CT close)
• Platform: Proprietary web-based, basic but functional
• Contracts: ES, NQ, YM, RTY, CL, GC, major contracts

Trading Pit (Rithmic/NinjaTrader):

• Execution: Professional-grade, sub-tick slippage with Rithmic
• Overnight: Full overnight and multi-day holds allowed
• Platform: Rithmic (lowest latency), NinjaTrader (full automation)
• Contracts: Same major contracts as E8

Verdict: Trading Pit wins on futures across every dimension except payout speed. Overnight capability alone eliminates E8 for swing traders. Professional platform access (Rithmic, NinjaTrader) is industry-standard. E8's proprietary platform works but can't compete.

Crypto Comparison

E8 (TradeLocker):

• Pairs: BTC/USD, ETH/USD, 15+ altcoins (ADA, SOL, MATIC, etc.)
• Spreads: 50-100 bps on BTC/USD (acceptable for crypto)
• Execution: Clean, minimal slippage
• Platform: Same TradeLocker as forex (convenient)

Trading Pit:

• Pairs: None (crypto not offered)

Verdict: E8 wins by default. For crypto traders, Trading Pit isn't an option.

Platform Access and Quality

E8's Platform Approach

TradeLocker (Forex/Crypto):

• Web-based, no installation needed
• Clean interface for manual trading
• No EA/bot support (manual only)
• Adequate for price action trading

E8 Futures (Proprietary):

• Web-based futures platform
• Clean DOM, fast fills
• No automation support
• Works fine for manual day trading

Limitations: No MT5, no Rithmic, no NinjaTrader. If you need professional platforms or automation, E8 doesn't accommodate it.

Best for: Manual traders who don't need professional tools and value web-based convenience.

The Trading Pit's Platform Approach

Forex platforms:

• MT5 (full EA support, professional-grade, extensive tools)
• DXtrade (web-based alternative)

Futures platforms:

• Rithmic (lowest latency execution)
• NinjaTrader (automation, backtesting, market replay)
• Tradovate (modern interface)

Advantages: Industry-standard professional platforms across both asset classes. Full automation support. Traders can use familiar tools from retail trading.

Best for: Professional traders, automated strategy users, traders needing specific platform features.

Platform Winner: Depends on Your Needs

Manual price action traders: E8's platforms are adequate. Simpler, web-based, functional.

Automated traders: Trading Pit's MT5 (forex) and NinjaTrader (futures) support is essential. E8 can't run bots.

Scalpers needing speed: Trading Pit's Rithmic beats E8's proprietary futures platform on latency.

Convenience-focused traders: E8's web-based platforms (no installation) win on simplicity.

Overnight Trading: Trading Pit's Critical Advantage

E8's Intraday-Only Futures Rule

E8 forces futures positions to close at 3:10 PM CT daily. No overnight holds. No multi-day positions.

Who this eliminates: Futures swing traders whose edge comes from holding ES, NQ, or other contracts 2-7 days through overnight sessions.

Trading Pit's Unlimited Overnight Holds

The Trading Pit allows full overnight and multi-day futures positions with no restrictions. Hold ES for 1 night or 7 nights—your choice.

Who this benefits: Swing traders, gap traders, multi-day trend followers, anyone whose futures strategy requires overnight exposure.

The Strategic Impact

Example swing strategy: Identify 3-day ES trend. Enter Monday morning at 5100, target 5220 by Thursday afternoon.

With E8: Forced to close Monday 3:10 PM, re-enter Tuesday morning (losing overnight gap moves, paying extra commissions), close Tuesday 3:10 PM, re-enter Wednesday—your edge disintegrates.

With Trading Pit: Enter Monday, hold through Monday night, Tuesday, Tuesday night, Wednesday, exit Thursday. Capture full 120-point move including overnight gaps.

For day traders: If you're closing all positions before 3:00 PM anyway, this difference is irrelevant. E8's intraday rule doesn't affect pure day traders.

For swing traders: This is non-negotiable. Trading Pit is your only option between these two firms.

Evaluation Structures and Costs

E8's Four-Path Approach

E8 Track (50K): $150

• 3-step evaluation (8% + 5% + 3% targets)
• 50-80 days typical time to funding
• Budget option, most steps

E8 Classic (50K): $250

• 2-step evaluation (8% + 4% targets)
• 35-55 days typical
• Scaling (1% drawdown increases)

E8 Signature (50K): $300

• 1-step evaluation (6% target)
• 20-40 days typical
• On-demand withdrawals, no consistency rule

E8 One (50K): $220-$720

• 1-step customizable (6-18% target, 4-14% drawdown, 80-100% split)
• 20-60 days depending on configuration
• Full optimization control

E8's advantage: Variety. Four distinct paths for different trader types (budget, speed, customization, verification).

The Trading Pit's Two-Path Approach

Standard Evaluation (50K): $220-$350

• 1-2 step depending on specific program
• 25-45 days typical
• 25% scaling from first payout

Direct Funded (if offered): $400-$600

• Skip evaluation, instant funding
• Higher cost but immediate trading

Trading Pit's advantage: Simplicity. Fewer choices, clearer decision. Focus is on the scaling benefit rather than evaluation variety.

Cost-to-Funded Comparison

E8 Signature path:

• Cost: $300
• Target: $3,000 (6%)
• Time: 30 days average
• First payout: $2,400 (80%)
• Net: $2,100
• Account after first payout: Still 50K

Trading Pit Standard path:

• Cost: $300
• Target: $3,500-4,000 (7-8%)
• Time: 35 days average
• First payout: $2,800-3,200 (80%)
• Net: $2,500-2,900
• Account after first payout: 62.5K (25% scale)

Trading Pit wins on first-payout net and delivers immediate scaling benefit that E8 doesn't offer.

But E8's 30-day average beats Trading Pit's 35 days, and E8's 2-5 day payout delivery means receiving funds 5-10 days sooner than Trading Pit's 7-14 days.

Long-Term Growth Scenarios

Scenario 1: 6-Month Active Trader

Profile: Makes $3K monthly profit consistently, withdraws bi-weekly ($1,500 each time).

E8 path:

• 6 months = 12 withdrawals
• Payout speed: 3 days average = 36 days total waiting
• Account balance after 6 months: 50K (unchanged)
• Total earnings: $18,000 (6 months × $3K)
• Keep at 80%: $14,400

Trading Pit path:

• 6 months = 12 withdrawals
• Payout speed: 10 days average = 120 days total waiting
• Account balance after 6 months: ~150K (scaled 6+ times at 25% each)
• Total earnings: $22,000+ (larger balance = more profit potential)
• Keep at 80% first, 90% after: ~$19,000

Trading Pit advantage: Higher total earnings due to scaling (~$4,600 more), significantly larger account (150K vs 50K).

E8 advantage: 84 fewer days waiting for payouts (better cash flow for living expenses).

Winner depends on: Cash flow needs (E8) vs total profit growth (Trading Pit).

Scenario 2: 12-Month Long-Term Grower

Profile: Makes $3K-5K monthly (increases with balance), withdraws monthly, focused on capital growth.

E8 path:

• 12 months = 12 withdrawals
• Account stays 50K entire time
• Total earnings: $36,000-$42,000 (limited by static balance)
• To access 100K: Buy new eval ($400-$600)
• To access 200K: Buy two more evals ($1,200-$1,800 total)

Trading Pit path:

• 12 months = 12 withdrawals
• Account scales: 50K → 62.5K → 78K → 97.5K → 122K → 150K+ → 200K+ → 250K+
• Total earnings: $60,000-$80,000+ (larger balance = larger profits)
• To access 250K: Zero additional cost (scaling handles it)

Trading Pit wins decisively for long-term growth. The 25% scaling compounds so aggressively that you're trading 250K+ by month 10-12 versus E8's static 50K requiring $1,500+ in additional evaluations to access comparable capital.

Scenario 3: Multi-Account Runner

Profile: Prefers running 3-4 separate 50K accounts rather than one large 200K account.

E8 path:

• Buy 3 E8 Signature accounts: $900
• Run 3 × 50K = $150K total capital
• Diversify strategies across accounts
• Independent payout timelines (3-5 days each)

Trading Pit path:

• Buy 1 Trading Pit account: $300
• Scale to 150K over time
• Single account management
• One payout timeline (7-14 days)

E8 wins for multi-account preference. If you strategically want separate accounts (strategy diversification, psychological separation, independent risk management), E8's variety and lower per-account cost ($300 vs Trading Pit's $300-450) makes running multiple accounts more accessible.

Decision Framework: E8 or Trading Pit?

Choose E8 Markets if:

1. You need crypto access (BTC, ETH, altcoins)—Trading Pit doesn't offer crypto
2. Payout speed is critical (2-5 days vs 7-14 days matters for cash flow)
3. You're a short-term rotator (3-6 months per firm, scaling doesn't compound enough)
4. You prefer multiple accounts (3-5 separate 50K accounts vs one large scaled account)
5. You're a futures day trader (intraday-only rule doesn't affect you)
6. Lower entry cost matters ($150-$300 vs $220-$450)
7. Web-based platforms adequate (don't need MT5, Rithmic, NinjaTrader)
8. Budget-conscious testing (E8 Track $150 is lowest-risk prop entry)

Choose The Trading Pit if:

1. You're committed long-term (12-24+ months, scaling compounds significantly)
2. Capital growth is priority (50K → 250K path without buying new evals)
3. You're a futures swing trader (need overnight position holds)
4. You need professional platforms (MT5 for forex automation, Rithmic/NinjaTrader for futures)
5. You don't trade crypto (forex + futures covers all your markets)
6. Slower payouts acceptable (7-14 days works for your cash management)
7. Single large account preferred (manage one 200K account vs four 50K accounts)
8. Scaling amplifies your edge (your strategy works equally well at 50K and 200K)

The Hybrid Approach

Many successful multi-asset traders run both:

E8 for:

• Crypto trading (BTC/ETH positions)
• Day trading futures (ES/NQ intraday)
• Fast withdrawals when cash flow matters

Trading Pit for:

• Forex swing trades (EUR/USD, GBP/USD multi-day positions)
• Futures swing trades (ES/NQ overnight holds)
• Long-term capital growth (let one account scale to 200K+)

This diversifies firm risk, leverages each firm's strengths, and provides access to all three asset classes with optimal rules for each strategy type.

FAQ: E8 vs The Trading Pit

Which is faster: E8 or Trading Pit payouts?

E8 is significantly faster. E8: 2-5 days (3.1 day average). Trading Pit: 7-14 days (9.8 day average). E8 wins by 6.7 days per withdrawal based on my testing. E8 ranks #2 overall, Trading Pit ranks #9-10.

Does The Trading Pit offer crypto like E8?

No. The Trading Pit offers forex and futures only. E8 offers forex, futures, and crypto. For crypto traders (BTC, ETH, altcoins), E8 is the only option between these two firms.

Which scales better: E8 or Trading Pit?

The Trading Pit scales far better. Trading Pit: 25% balance increase per withdrawal (50K → 62.5K → 78K → 97.5K → 122K). E8: minimal scaling (1% drawdown increases on Classic/Track, balance stays fixed). For long-term growth, Trading Pit wins decisively.

Can you hold futures positions overnight on E8?

No. E8 forces intraday-only futures with close at 3:10 PM CT. The Trading Pit allows unlimited overnight holds. For futures swing traders, Trading Pit is the only option.

Can you use MT5 or Rithmic on E8?

No. E8 uses TradeLocker (forex/crypto) and proprietary E8 Futures platform. The Trading Pit offers MT5, DXtrade (forex), Rithmic, NinjaTrader (futures). If these platforms are essential, choose Trading Pit.

Which is cheaper: E8 or Trading Pit?

E8 is cheaper upfront. E8: $150-$300 for 50K standard accounts. Trading Pit: $220-$450. But Trading Pit's 25% scaling means no additional costs to reach 150K-250K, while E8 requires buying new evaluations ($1,200-$1,800 total) for comparable capital.

Does E8 or Trading Pit have better forex spreads?

E8 has slightly tighter spreads. E8: 0.8-1.2 pips EUR/USD. Trading Pit: 0.9-1.4 pips. E8 wins by 0.1-0.2 pips per trade. But Trading Pit's MT5 platform access may outweigh spread difference for automated traders.

Which is better for multi-asset traders?

Depends on asset mix. E8 wins if you trade crypto (only firm offering it). Trading Pit wins if you trade forex + futures only and value overnight futures capability. Both offer solid forex and futures—E8 adds crypto, Trading Pit adds overnight futures and better platforms.

How long does it take to scale to 150K on Trading Pit?

With consistent monthly profits and withdrawals, approximately 6-8 months: 50K → 62.5K (month 1) → 78K (month 2) → 97.5K (month 3) → 122K (month 4) → 150K+ (month 6). E8 would require buying 3 separate 50K evaluations at $900-$1,500 total cost to access 150K.

Can you run multiple accounts on both firms?

Yes. Both allow multiple accounts. E8 offers 4 evaluation types, making it easier to run varied account structures (Track + Signature + One). Trading Pit offers fewer evaluation types but 25% scaling means one account can grow to replace multiple smaller accounts over time.

Bottom line: E8 Markets wins for traders prioritizing speed, crypto access, and lower costs. The Trading Pit wins for long-term growers who value aggressive scaling, overnight futures capability, and professional platforms. Both are excellent multi-asset prop firms—your time horizon and asset preferences determine the better fit.

Use code VIBES for 35% off E8 evaluations.

‍